1 min read
7 Most Common Landlord Insurance Claims and How to Avoid Them
Landlord insurance exists because rental property generates claims that owner-occupied homes rarely see: tenants, turnover, vacancy periods, and...
3 min read
Neal Fusco
:
Updated on June 22, 2026
Quick Answer: Landlord insurance protects property owners who rent to tenants. It covers the building, your liability as a landlord, and lost rental income after a covered loss. It is not legally required, but a standard homeowners policy will not cover a rented property, so most landlords need it.
Landlord insurance is an often overlooked necessity for anyone who rents a property to a tenant. Below are clear answers to the questions we hear most, so you can decide what coverage you actually need.
Renting out a property? Protect it the right way.
We shop landlord coverage across top carriers and build a policy around your property, your tenants, and your risk. Get a quote in minutes.
Get a Landlord QuoteLandlord insurance is a policy for property owners who rent their home, condo, or building to someone else. Landlords face risks a primary homeowner does not, and a standard homeowners policy usually will not pay a claim once the property is rented out. Landlord insurance fills that gap. The Insurance Information Institute outlines the same basic structure.
Most landlord policies are built around three core coverages, with optional add-ons to match your property.
Property damage
Repairs or rebuilds the dwelling and attached fixtures after a covered loss like fire, storm, or vandalism.
Liability protection
Pays medical and legal costs if a tenant or guest is injured on your property and you are found responsible.
Loss of rental income
Replaces the rent you lose while a covered property is being repaired and cannot be occupied.
Common add-ons include rent guarantee, expanded natural disaster coverage, and protection for any staff you employ. For a full side-by-side with tenant coverage, see landlord insurance vs. renters insurance.
Two gaps catch landlords off guard. First, your policy does not cover your tenant's personal belongings. That is what their renters insurance is for, which is why many landlords require it in the lease. Second, like any property policy, it excludes flooding and gradual wear and tear, which need separate coverage or maintenance.
Cost depends on the property location, number of units, the building's age and condition, your coverage limits, and safety features. As a rough guide:
| Property type | Typical annual premium |
|---|---|
| Single condo or small unit | $500 to $1,200 |
| Single-family rental ($200k dwelling) | About $2,000 |
| Multi-unit or higher-value property | $2,500 and up |
For Illinois-specific numbers and what drives them, see our cost of landlord insurance in Illinois breakdown.
Protect your rental and your rental income
As an independent brokerage, we compare landlord policies across 20+ carriers to find the right coverage at the right price, whether you own one unit or fifty.
Get a Landlord Quote Call 833-776-4671Landlord insurance is a policy for property owners who rent a home, condo, or building to a tenant. It covers the building, your liability as a landlord, and lost rental income, filling the gap a standard homeowners policy leaves once a property is rented out.
Most policies cover three core things: property damage to the dwelling, liability if a tenant or guest is injured, and loss of rental income while the property is being repaired. Optional add-ons include rent guarantee, expanded disaster coverage, and employer liability.
No. Your landlord policy covers the building and your liability, not the tenant's personal property. Tenants protect their own belongings with renters insurance, which is why many landlords require it in the lease.
It varies by location, number of units, the building's age and condition, and your coverage limits. A single unit can be as little as $500 a year, while a single-family rental on a $200,000 dwelling averages around $2,000. Multi-unit and higher-value properties cost more.
It is not required by law. However, if you have a mortgage, your lender will almost always require it, and going without it leaves you exposed to losses that can exceed $100,000. See what is expected in our guide on the landlord insurance required in Illinois.
Yes. A standard homeowners policy generally will not pay a claim once you rent the property to a tenant. Renting out a home changes how it is used and the risk involved, so it requires a dedicated landlord policy.
Yes. Owners and property managers with several rentals can insure multiple properties, often under one program for a discount. If you manage properties for others, you may also need coverage for the management firm itself, which is property management insurance.
If your property is damaged and the claim is denied by your homeowners policy and the tenant's renters policy, you can be left paying out of pocket, sometimes more than $100,000. A liability lawsuit from an injured tenant can cost even more. Landlord insurance is the affordable safeguard against both.
Reviewed by Neal Fusco, VP Commercial Lines
25+ years placing landlord, habitational, and commercial property coverage across Illinois and 40+ states.
1 min read
Landlord insurance exists because rental property generates claims that owner-occupied homes rarely see: tenants, turnover, vacancy periods, and...
1 min read
Quick Answer: Yes, in most cases landlord insurance covers loss of rent. If a covered event such as a fire, storm, or burst pipe makes your rental...
1 min read
"Is landlord insurance worth it" sounds like a cost-benefit question, but for most rental property owners it is really a different question in...