• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Pro Insurance Group Logo

Pro Insurance Group

Personal & Business Insurance Agency

  • Business
    • Business Income
    • Commercial Umbrella
    • Cyber Liability
    • Directors & Officers
    • Employee Benefits Liability
    • Employment Practices Liability
    • Errors & Omissions
    • Fiduciary Liability
    • General Liability
    • Group Health
    • Non-owned Auto
    • Pollution Liability
    • Product Recall
    • Workers Compensation
  • Personal
    • Auto
    • Home
    • Individual Health
    • Individual Life
  • Specialty
    • Bar & Restaurant
    • Electrician
    • HOA
    • Habitational / Landlord
    • Senior Living Facilities
    • Commercial Technology
    • Towing
    • Commercial Trucking
    • Family Entertainment Center
  • About
    • Blog
    • Contact
    • Multimedia
833.619.0770 Client Portal Request A Quote

Overpaying for Homeowners Insurance? 10 Tips for Illinois Homeowners to Compare Rates

February 17, 2025

focused busy Indian freelance accountant woman checking financial documents

Homeowners in Illinois pay an average of $189 per month for $300,000 in dwelling coverage. This rate comes out to around $2,300 per year, though it can be much higher depending on your home’s value or whether you use it as a place of business.

Despite high average costs, many homeowners in Illinois are still overpaying for insurance. By following these simple tips, you may be able to reduce your monthly premiums by hundreds of dollars while still maintaining adequate coverage for your property. When comparing rates, here are 10 things to keep in mind:

1. Higher Deductibles Can Deliver Lower Premiums

Many homeowners can pay less for the same coverage limits by opting for a higher deductible. This can be useful for homeowners who rarely file claims or have separate deductibles for more costly incidents, such as hail or windstorms. 

2. Policy Bundles Can Help You Save

By bundling your homeowners insurance with your auto policy, you can put your premiums under one roof. If your insurer offers a bundling discount, you may be able to maintain your current level of coverage at a lower rate simply by moving other policies to your homeowners insurance provider.

3. Different Providers Offer Unique Services

If you believe you are overpaying for homeowners insurance, you can shop for other providers. Ask for numerous quotes to learn what each company offers, including their claim filing services and bundling options.

4. Understand Cash Value vs Replacement Cost

Cash value and replacement cost are two possible reimbursement methods for a policy claim. Cash value policies reimburse homeowners for the current value of their structures or materials while replacement cost reimburses the actual cost of replacing or repairing the home. This represents a significant difference in the value of a homeowners insurance policy, especially for older heritage homes where depreciation can severely reduce a cash value claim.

5. Disaster-Proof Homes are Easier to Insure

roof severely damaged by strong winds, with missing shingles and exposed wooden beams

Disaster-proofing your home with storm shutters, shatter-proof glass, or stronger roofing materials can lower your premiums. Your insurer may reward your efforts to make your home more resilient to damage by charging less for your disaster coverage.

6. Home Security Upgrades Can Lead to Savings

Home security upgrades such as surveillance cameras, new locks, alarms, and more can make your home a safer investment for your insurer. They may offer lower premiums on theft protection following these upgrades.

7. Improve Your Credit Score for a Policy Reduction

Improving your credit score by reducing debts, paying off credit cards, and paying your mortgage on time may increase your policy provider’s confidence in your reliability. In fact, you might be overpaying for your current policy if your credit has improved in recent years. If you renegotiate, they may offer a lower premium. 

8. Remain Claim-Free

You may be overpaying for your policy if you file too many small claims since this flags your insurance company to treat your policy as a high-risk investment. Try to remain claim-free so you can switch providers with a clean record or renegotiate your current premiums.

9. Ask for Additional Discounts

You could be overpaying for insurance if you have not asked your agent about discounts specific to your situation. If your situation has recently changed, ask for a re-evaluation to determine your potential discounts. Running a business out of your home, for example, may change your coverage needs.

10. Review Your Policy Every Year

closeup house model over the sale representative offer the house price list and condition for house purchase or rental on the working space table in new house

If your situation has changed, your current insurance policy may include coverage you no longer need or coverage that is too little for your new asset value. An experienced financial advisor can compare your current liability limits to your current homeowner insurance needs to determine whether you should change your deductible, buy or remove coverages, bundle your policy, or switch providers.

Contact Pro Insurance Group For Affordable Homeowners Insurance in Illinois

At Pro Insurance Group, our experienced team can help you determine whether you’re overpaying for your home insurance. Often, homeowners come to us without knowing where to cut back or how to improve their premiums.

We offer custom insurance services to help homeowners in Illinois compare rates and find the best insurance for their situation. Contact our team today to learn how you can pay less for homeowners insurance without sacrificing the coverage you need.

Filed Under: Homeowners Insurance

Primary Sidebar

Have A Question?

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Recent Blogs

loaded european truck on motorway in sunset

The Top Factors That Impact Trucking Insurance Costs and How to Control Them

April 7, 2025

happy confident driver standing in front on his truck and looking at camera

Why Illinois Truckers Should Consider Non-Trucking Liability Insurance

March 31, 2025

truck driver sitting in his truck showing thumbs up

Why Truckers in Illinois Should Regularly Review Their Insurance Policies

March 24, 2025

Footer

Pro Insurance Group Logo
2521 Technology Drive, Ste 201 Elgin, IL 60124
833.619.0770
info@proinsgrp.com

Link to company Facebook page

Link to company Twitter page

Link to company LinkedIn page

Link to company YouTube page

Link to company Instagram page

Business Insurance

  • Business Income
  • Cyber Liability
  • Directors & Officers
  • Employee Benefits Liability
  • Employment Practices Liability
  • Errors & Omissions
  • Fiduciary Liability
  • General Liability
  • Group Health
  • Non-owned Auto
  • Pollution Liability
  • Product Recall

Personal Insurance

  • Auto
  • Home
  • Individual Health
  • Individual Life

Specialty Insurance

  • Bar & Restaurant
  • Electrician
  • Family Entertainment Center
  • Habitational / Landlord
  • HOA
  • Senior Living Facilities
  • Technology
  • Towing
  • Commercial Trucking

© 2025 Pro Insurance Group, LLC · Powered by 321 Web Marketing · Website Privacy Policy & Terms of Use